RSS icon Home icon
  • Greenwashing vs. Dishwashing

    Posted on September 18th, 2010 Cris 14 comments Add a comment >>

    As the Adirondack Green Circle was planning the recent Farm 2 Fork Festival held in Saranac Lake (September 4th), we wanted to keep the event as “green” as possible,. We tried to find ways to keep our veggie sample containers, Locavore Grill plates, and all other materials out of the long-term waste stream. That meant using paper for serving up the food and avoiding plastic, but what do you use to get those beets into your mouth?! One option that was explored was buying compostable forks and spoons that someone could just “process” in her home compost pile. Great (if pricey) solution, right?

    It turns out that the “compostable” part of such forks and spoons appears to be a marketing scam aimed at ecofriendly types, a.k.a. greenwashing. An informal study done in San Francisco of such forks and spoons that had been through the city’s commercial compost operation (composted for 60-90 days at high temperatures) showed that they were not only recognizable in their original form but you could probably just wash them off and use them over and over. (See detatils at Fake Plastic Fish.) It seems beyond anyone’s wildest imaginings that anyone’s backyard compost pile could even approach breaking this stuff down. Turns out there is a little cyberuniverse out there discussing this issue, and there are lots of ideas. See what WholeFoods has to say: link.

    Pictured above is our solution to this dilemma. The Green Circle bought a load of old flatware, from a local thrift store and the senior center. (And we asked folks to bring their own forks with them next time.) Buckets were put out for depositing the used utensils, and a Green Circle member (thanks, Susan!!!) took them home and ran them through her dishwasher. Someone will surely criticize using the dishwasher, but a lot of people told us they liked this simple, green, forward-thinking solution. And maybe next time folks really will bring their own forks.

     

    14 responses to “Greenwashing vs. Dishwashing” RSS icon

    • I think this is among the most vital info for me. And i’m glad reading your article. But want to remark on some general things, The web site style is wonderful, the articles is really great : D. Good job, cheers

    • This is my first time i visit right here. I found so many entertaining stuff within your weblog, especially its conversation. From the tons of comments on your content, I guess I ‘m not the only one having all the enjoyment here! Keep up the excellent work.

    • Great post. Very informative.

    • My programmer is trying to convince me to move to .net from PHP. I have always disliked the idea because of the costs. But he’s tryiong none the less. I’ve been using Movable-type on several websites for about a year and am anxious about switching to another platform. I have heard fantastic things about blogengine.net. Is there a way I can import all my wordpress posts into it? Any help would be greatly appreciated!

    • Appreciate it for sharing Greenwashing vs. Dishwashing @ with us keep update bro love your article about Greenwashing vs. Dishwashing @ .

    • This is an interesting catch 22 situation. Do you buy into the compostable materials out there and promote them as green or reject them based on current studies showing that they do not decompose as rapidly as they want us to think.

      I work for a food packaging distributor in Minneapolis, MN and sell all of these products to coffee shops, restaurants and coops. I believe more in the recycled paper products, hot cups, straws, etc. and their ability to break down in a landfill than the cornstarch and potato starch utensils, cups, and straws.

      We sell one line of cornstarch utensils made in China that the sales rep for that company swears passes what is called the burn test. In other words some cornstarchware is still held together by minimal amounts of plastic and when burned releases harmful byproduct into the air. The line we sell is said to be held together by a material harvested from sea shells and not plastic. Cornstarch alone does not make a strong enough utensil and needs another material to bond to.

      I read all of the studies out there and am still on the fence if these “new” “green” lines of disposables work or are just so much marketing.

      Sam H.

    • Nice to be traveling to your own website after much more, it’s long been several weeks to do. Properly this specific publish in which i’ve been silently laid pertaining to now prolonged. I’d like this approach write-up to finish great assignment within a university, in addition to it’s got similar matter along with your write-up. Thank you, terrific share..

    • Wonderful post. I really could not have detailed that better. I am not sure if all people will go along with you, nonetheless it probably does not matter. Keep up the excellent work.

    • I think those little forks were actually made in Tupper Lake at the Wooden Bowl Factory. Now closed.

      I always say “no straw thanks” when they are brought with the drink. Why do they bring them, anyway? Are the glasses dirty?

    • Hey, Josh and Kathy. Yes, what about those straws? I can’t imagine the “compostable” straws are any more biodegradable then the “compostable” eating utensils. It seems paper straws are available on the web but many of them seem to be relatively expensive “designer” straws (?!). I did see some reasonably-priced ones by Aardvark. What a good idea to make that switch, although I think maybe we could do without a lot of the straws that are more of a habit than a need.

      And those utensils Kathy mentions – sporks – seem to be making a comeback in a small way, but they still need to be tossed. Maybe each of us should carry a little camping bundle of the spoon, fork, and knife. Remember those? Wash them when you get home, maybe in boiling water in your ditty bag and hang to air dry. (Does anyone else remember those Girl Scout rules at camp???)

      Thanks for your comments!

    • Well, Josh, I’m old enough to remember when straws were made of paper…they definitely would be compostable. A straw only needs to last long enough to consume the drink it’s in and paper straws worked fine for that. There’s no need for them to be made of plastic.

      And does anyone remember those little wooden two pronged forks you used to get with an order of fries (real crinkle-cut fries, not the wimpy stringy fast food kind)?

    • Very interesting. Does anyone know if the same holds true for compostable straws? A local restaurant where I work uses them and I wonder if they really work. Thanks


    Leave a reply